Intraday Trading Indicator Combinations: Reddit Insights vs. 2025 Research

Reddit Factors

Top combinations: VWAP +20-EMA +RSI(14) (avoiding MACD as laggy) and VWAP + trendlines + daily support/resistance.
Skepticism: Some users reject RSI/MACD; others rely on price action (trapped trader reversals) or time-of-day over indicators.
Three-filter system mentioned: direction (higher-timeframe momentum), volatility (ATR), trigger (VWAP deviations/RSI/volume impulse).
A 14-year trader abandons indicators entirely.

Research Findings

2025 effective VWAP combinations: VWAP+std dev bands (dynamic SR), VWAP+multiple EMAs (trend/gaps), VWAP+RSI+MACD (momentum/divergence), VWAP+Volume Profile (institutional levels), VWAP+ATR (risk management), VWAP+Order Flow (smart money) [2][3][4][13].
Mixed but positive results for RSI/MACD with VWAP+volume: reduces false signals, improves trade quality (varies by market/timeframe) [1][10].
Confluence beats single indicators; fundamental data complements technicals but combinations help [12].

Synthesis

Agreement: Confluence of indicators improves reliability; VWAP as core anchor.
Contradictions: Reddit split on RSI/MACD (some laggy, research effective if optimized); some traders abandon indicators (research supports combinations).
Implications: Test VWAP-based multi-filter systems and optimize parameters for market/timeframe.

Risks & Opportunities

Risks: Over-reliance on laggy indicators (MACD for intraday), poor parameter optimization.
Opportunities: Leverage VWAP+volatility/momentum combinations; integrate order flow/institutional levels for edge.

Related Stocks