Analysis of the Impact of Airbag Defect Incidents on Stock Valuations of Automakers and Suppliers

Based on information obtained from searches and financial data analysis, I now provide you with a systematic analysis of the impact of airbag defect incidents on the stock valuations of automakers and suppliers.

---

According to the emergency safety warning issued by the U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), defective airbags have caused the deaths of two drivers in car crashes[1][2]. This crisis mainly involves the following core issues:

• This is the largest safety recall in automotive history, involving more than
  70 million airbags
  in over
  42 million vehicles
  worldwide[2]
• Cumulative recall costs are estimated to exceed
  $25 billion
  , directly leading to the bankruptcy of supplier Takata[3]
• NHTSA has confirmed that
  28 people in the U.S. have died
  due to defective Takata airbags, with
  12 fatalities
  occurring in vehicles with unresolved recall notices that were not repaired (between 2015-2024)[2]

• In December 2025, a 2010 GMC Sierra pickup truck had an airbag rupture in a crash, injuring a passenger[2]
• The vehicle had an unresolved recall notice for Takata airbags, and General Motors and NHTSA are jointly investigating this incident[2]
• To date, General Motors has only completed repairs on approximately
  50%
  of the vehicles covered by its Takata airbag recall, with a large number of vehicles still unrepaired[2]

---

Automaker	Number of Recalls	Recalled Vehicles (Millions)	Market Capitalization (Billion USD)	1-Year Return (%)	Price-to-Earnings (P/E)
Ford (F)	94	5.99M	$54.71	+43.98%	11.83x
General Motors (GM)	32	1.20M	$77.65	+66.71%	26.33x
Toyota ™	28	3.20M	$298.50	+24.98%	10.24x
Honda (HMC)	25	1.56M	$44.07	+6.95%	10.53x
Stellantis	30	0.75M	$29.18	-18.09%	2.88x
Tesla (TSLA)	15+	5.78M (Software Recalls)	$1,440.00	+10.88%	273.94x

: Stock data of each company is based on market closing data as of January 14, 2026[0]; recall data is based on public reports[4][5]

1. Ford Motor (Recall Leader in 2025)
   :
   • Leads the industry in both the number of recalls (94) and the number of recalled vehicles (5.99 million)[4][5]
   • Approximately 230,000 Bronco/Bronco Sport models are involved due to airbag and door lock issues[4]
   • Despite frequent recalls, its 1-year stock return reached
     +43.98%
     , delivering solid performance[0]

2. General Motors (Impact of the GMC Sierra Incident)
   :
   • The completion rate of Takata airbag recalls is only 50%, posing ongoing risks[2]
   • Its stock performance is strong, with a 1-year return of
     +66.71%
     , the best among mainstream automakers[0]
   • The airbag rupture incident under investigation may bring legal risks[2]

3. Stellantis’s Underperformance
   :
   • Its 1-year return is
     -18.09%
     , the only automaker with a negative return[0]
   • Faces a recall of approximately 250,000 Chrysler Pacifica and Voyager vehicles due to airbag malfunctions[4]
   • Recall costs account for a relatively high proportion of sales, with an average recall cost of approximately $743.20 per vehicle[5]

---

Incident	Total Cost (Billion USD)	Number of Fatalities	Unit Cost
Volkswagen Dieselgate	$35.0B	0	Over $3,500/vehicle
Takata Airbags	$25.0B	28	Over $400/vehicle
GM Ignition Switch	$4.1B	124	Over $800/vehicle
Multiple Ford Recalls	$3.5B	3	Over $500/vehicle
Toyota Accelerator Pedal	$2.4B	0	Over $800/vehicle

: Historical recall cost data is based on public financial reports[3]

Estimated based on the industry average recall cost of

(including parts replacement, labor, litigation reserves, and administrative expenses):

Automaker	Recalled Vehicles	Estimated Recall Cost
Ford	5.99M	$3.89B
Toyota	3.20M	$2.08B
Honda	1.56M	$1.01B
General Motors	1.20M	$0.78B
Stellantis	0.75M	$0.49B

:

• Personal Injury Lawsuits
  : The 28 fatalities confirmed by NHTSA may trigger large-scale wrongful death lawsuits[2]
• Punitive Damages
  : If intentional concealment of defects is discovered, automakers may face punitive damages
• Regulatory Penalties
  : NHTSA can impose civil penalties of up to $22,500 per violation
• Pressure on Recall Completion Rate
  : Approximately 72.7 million vehicles on U.S. roads have unresolved recalls[6], with Takata airbags accounting for a large proportion

:

• After Takata’s bankruptcy, insufficient supply of replacement airbags has led to extended repair cycles[3]
• Airbag technical standards and quality control processes have been forced to undergo comprehensive reforms[3]

---

• Negative Factors
  : Major recall news typically causes a short-term stock price decline of 1-3%
• Stellantis Case
  : Its continued weak stock performance (-14.26% in 1 month, only +0.30% in 6 months) is related to its frequent recalls and product quality issues[0]

Impact Dimension	Analysis Conclusion
Profit Impact	Recall costs are usually reflected as one-time expenses in the quarterly financial report, with limited impact on long-term profitability
Valuation Multiples	Ford (11.83x P/E) and Toyota (10.24x P/E) maintain industry-normal levels; Stellantis’s significantly undervalued (2.88x P/E) reflects the market’s pricing of its quality risks
Cash Flow	Large-scale recalls may affect free cash flow for 1-2 quarters, but major automakers have sufficient cash reserves
Brand Reputation	In the long run, persistent recall issues may affect brand value and customer loyalty

High Number of Recalls (>50) + High Volatility (>25%) = High Risk
├── Ford: 94 recalls + 28.5% volatility → Need Attention
├── Stellantis: 30 recalls + 35.2% volatility → Relatively High Risk
└── GM: 32 recalls + 32.1% volatility → Need Attention

Low Number of Recalls (<30) + Low Volatility (<25%) = Relatively Stable
├── Toyota: 28 recalls + 22.3% volatility → Risk Controllable
├── Honda: 25 recalls + 18.7% volatility → Relatively Low Risk
└── Tesla: Software Recalls Dominant + High Valuation → Need to Differentiate Nature

---

:

• Has the highest recall frequency but delivers solid stock performance, indicating that the market has fully priced in the risks
• Analyst consensus is “Hold”, with a target price of $12.25, which is lower than the current price of $13.98[0]
• Risk: Persistent high-frequency recalls may erode profit margins

:

• Delivers an impressive 1-year return of +66.71%, with an analyst consensus of “Buy”[0]
• Risk: The investigation results of the GMC Sierra incident may trigger new legal risks[2]

:

• Has the largest market capitalization ($298.5 billion), with stable performance and leading industry profit margins (net profit margin of 9.38%)[0]
• Relatively low recall frequency and volatility, with controllable risks

:

• Has weak stock performance and is significantly undervalued (2.88x P/E)[0]
• Need to assess whether its product quality issues affect long-term competitiveness

Risk Type	Severity	Duration
Takata Legacy Issues	High	May persist until 2027
Newly Discovered Airbag Defects	Medium-High	Uncertain
Supply Chain Bottlenecks	Medium	1-2 Years
Increase in Legal Lawsuits	Medium-High	Ongoing

• Defensive Investors
  : Prioritize brands with lower recall frequencies such as Toyota and Honda
• Opportunistic Investors
  : Ford’s current valuation is reasonable (11.83x P/E), consider accumulating on dips
• Risk Averters
  : Remain cautious about Stellantis until its product quality issues show significant improvement

---

The impact of airbag defects on the automotive industry is multi-dimensional:

1. Financial Impact
   : Cumulative costs of Takata-related recalls exceed $25 billion, and the total estimated recall costs of major automakers in 2025 are approximately $8 billion[3]

2. Legal Risks
   : 28 fatalities and persistent unresolved recalls (approximately 72.7 million vehicles on the road) constitute major liability risks[2][6]

3. Stock Valuations
   : Judging from stock performance, the market has differentiated pricing for recall risks. Despite frequent recalls, Ford and General Motors have strong stock performance; Stellantis’s weak performance reflects an increase in its comprehensive risk premium

4. Long-Term Trends
   : The increase in software recalls (affecting 5.77 million Tesla vehicles in 2025) is changing the industry’s recall landscape[5]

When evaluating automakers, investors should comprehensively consider recall frequency, completion rate, legal risk exposure, and valuation levels, rather than focusing solely on the number of recalls.

---

[1] Vehicle Safety Firm - “Vehicle Safety News” (https://www.vehiclesafetyfirm.com/vehicle-safety-news/)

[2] CBT News - “GM, NHTSA investigate air bag rupture in recalled GMC Sierra crash” (https://www.cbtnews.com/gm-nhtsa-investigate-air-bag-rupture-in-recalled-gmc-sierra-crash-wsj-reports/)

[3] Yahoo Autos - “Wildly Expensive Car Blunders” (https://autos.yahoo.com/policy-and-environment/articles/wildly-expensive-car-blunders-123025239.html)

[4] Torque News - “The 5 Carmakers With The Most Recalls In 2025” (https://www.torquenews.com/17992/are-5-carmakers-most-recalls-2025)

[5] EpicVin - “Cars With the Most Recalls in 2025” (https://epicvin.com/blog/cars-with-the-most-recalls-in-2025)

[6] 12365auto - “Automobile Recalls” (https://www.12365auto.com/zhgg/index.shtml)

[0] Jinling API Market Data (as of January 14, 2026)