Assessment of the Impact of India's Spectrum Fee Cap Policy on Vodafone Idea and the Indian Telecom Industry

Based on the latest collected information, I will provide you with a systematic and comprehensive analysis report.

---

On December 31, 2025, the Indian government announced a spectrum fee cap policy for Vodafone Idea, freezing the annual payment cap for the company’s past spectrum fees until 2035 [1][2]. This policy provides critical financial relief for Vodafone Idea, enabling it to allocate more resources to network construction and market competition.

Specifically, the government has taken two important measures:

• AGR (Adjusted Gross Revenue) Relief
  : Freeze Vodafone Idea’s AGR debt of approximately 876.95 billion Indian rupees until 2032; previously, this debt was scheduled to start being repaid from March 2026 [3]
• Installment Repayment Arrangement
  : The re-evaluated AGR debt will be repaid in equal annual installments between 2036 and 2041, while the company only needs to pay 12.4 billion Indian rupees annually over the next six years [4]

The Indian government, as the largest shareholder of Vodafone Idea, holds approximately 49% of the company’s shares (converted approximately 530.83 billion Indian rupees of debt into equity in two tranches in February 2023 and April 2025) [5]. The core considerations for the government to introduce this policy are:

• Prevent the Indian telecom market from fully evolving into a duopoly
• Maintain the industry’s competitive ecosystem and keep market vitality
• Protect the value of state-owned assets (the value of the government’s shareholding)

---

With the support of the government’s policy, Vodafone Idea is actively considering debt financing to promote its growth strategy:

Financing Element	Details
Financing Purpose	Upgrade network infrastructure to enhance competitiveness with Jio and Airtel
Financing Channels	Domestic and global lending institutions
Financing Scale	Not publicly disclosed, but the expected amount is substantial
Supporting Plan	Equity financing negotiations with Tillman Global Holdings are still ongoing

Although the policy offers breathing room, Vodafone Idea still faces severe financial challenges:

• Spectrum Debt
  : Approximately 1.17 trillion Indian rupees (around 1.2 trillion Indian rupees), with a repayment deadline until 2044 [3][6]
• AGR Debt
  : Approximately 876.95 billion Indian rupees, with the repayment period extended after restructuring
• Annual Repayment Pressure
  : The current EBITDA cannot meet the needs of capital expenditures and spectrum debt repayment [6]

Emkay Global, in its research note dated January 1, 2026, maintained its “Sell” rating with a target price of only ₹6. The institution stated: “While the relief package addresses the AGR debt issue, Vodafone Idea still has 1.2 trillion Indian rupees in deferred spectrum payment obligations, with significant payment arrangements during FY26 to FY44. The current EBITDA is insufficient to cover capital expenditures or spectrum debt repayment, and the company needs additional relief or financing to address these challenges.” [6]

• Government policy support reduces immediate debt repayment pressure and improves debt sustainability
• As a government-held enterprise, it may receive more favorable financing terms
• Debt financing can avoid further equity dilution (although the government is already the largest shareholder)

• High leverage may affect credit ratings and financing costs
• Compared with Jio and Airtel, the debt scale is relatively small, limiting competitive advantages
• The long repayment cycle of spectrum debt means the financial burden will persist

---

According to October 2025 data from the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI), the Indian telecom market has quietly evolved into a de facto duopoly:

Operator	Market Share	User Base	Share Trend
Reliance Jio	41.36%	506 million	Continuous growth, the biggest beneficiary
Bharti Airtel	33.59%	364 million	Steady growth
Vodafone Idea	17.13%	Approximately 127 million	Continuous share loss
BSNL (State-owned)	7.9%	29 million	Market share eroded

• Jio’s market share increased significantly, mainly gaining users from Vodafone Idea and BSNL [7]
• Airtel maintained steady growth
• Vodafone Idea and BSNL continued to see their market shares shrink

Operator	Net User Change	Total Users
Reliance Jio	+8.3 million	>506 million
Bharti Airtel	+1.4 million	~364 million
Vodafone Idea	-1 million	Continuous decline

After 9 consecutive months of user growth, Vodafone Idea lost approximately 3.5 million users again in Q3 2025 [8], indicating increasing competitive pressure.

Operator	ARPU (INR)	ARPU (USD)
Bharti Airtel	256	$2.83
Reliance Jio	211	$2.33
Vodafone Idea	167	$1.85

Vodafone Idea’s ARPU is significantly lower than that of its competitors, which reflects:

• Relatively lower user quality
• Migration of high-value users to Jio and Airtel
• Restricted revenue growth due to lagging 5G business rollout

1. First-mover Advantage
   : Jio and Airtel launched commercial 5G services earlier than Vodafone Idea
2. Fixed Wireless Access (FWA) Business
   : Both have launched FWA services, which is one of the fastest-growing segments in India and can achieve higher home broadband ARPU
3. 5G User Scale
   : As of July 2025, India’s 365 million 5G users are mainly divided between Jio and Airtel [7]

• Launched commercial 5G services only in 2025, missing the first-mover advantage
• Did not participate in the FWA market, missing high-value growth opportunities
• 5G user acquisition speed is far lower than that of competitors

---

1. Alleviated Financial Pressure
   : The freezing of AGR debt and spectrum fee cap provide valuable breathing room
2. Improved Financing Environment
   : Policy support may improve the company’s credit status and financing conditions
3. Released Operating Capital
   : More funds can be allocated to network upgrades and market promotion

1. Temporary Solution, Not a Cure
   : Total debt remains unchanged, and long-term financial burden persists
2. Difficult to Reverse Market Share Loss
   : The user loss trend has not been effectively curbed after the policy was introduced
3. Widening Competitive Gap
   : The gap in 5G and FWA businesses with Jio and Airtel continues to widen

• Vodafone Idea gains a valuable adjustment period, which is expected to slow down the rate of market share loss
• The market still maintains a four-operator pattern of “two large + two small”
• The competitive situation temporarily tends to balance

• Policy relief can only delay but not prevent the deepening of the duopoly pattern
• If Vodafone Idea cannot effectively enhance its competitiveness, the market will further concentrate on Jio and Airtel
• The positioning and role of BSNL as a state-owned operator will become more important

1. Policy Implementation Risk
   : The decision of the AGR Re-evaluation Committee still has uncertainties [4]
2. Financing Implementation Risk
   : Whether debt financing can be realized as planned remains uncertain
3. Equity Financing Risk
   : The outcome of equity investment negotiations with Tillman Global Holdings is uncertain
4. Market Competition Risk
   : The continuous expansion of Jio and Airtel may offset the policy effects

---

Rating Agency	Rating	Target Price	Rating Date
Emkay Global	Sell	₹6	January 1, 2026

Analysts generally believe that although the government has provided policy support, the improvement of Vodafone Idea’s fundamentals still needs time to be verified.

1. User Growth Recovery
   : Whether the company can stop the user loss trend
2. ARPU Improvement
   : Ability to acquire high-value users
3. 5G Network Deployment Progress
   : Whether the gap with competitors can be narrowed
4. Financing Progress
   : The specific implementation of debt financing and equity financing
5. Financial Indicator Improvement
   : EBITDA growth, debt structure optimization

Scenario	Probability	Trigger Conditions	Expected Results
Optimistic Scenario	25%	Smooth financing, resumed user growth, accelerated 5G deployment	Market share stabilizes, competitive position improves
Base Scenario	50%	Partial financing realization, slowed user loss	Maintains survival but gap widens
Pessimistic Scenario	25%	Financing hindered, continuous user loss	Further market share shrinkage, forced to seek more government support

---

The Indian government’s spectrum fee cap policy provides Vodafone Idea with a valuable strategic buffer period, but it cannot fundamentally reverse the trend of the Indian telecom market evolving into a duopoly. For Vodafone Idea to achieve sustainable recovery, it needs to make breakthroughs in the following aspects:

1. Successfully complete debt financing
   , ensuring funds for network upgrades
2. Stop the user loss trend
   , improving user quality and ARPU
3. Accelerate 5G network deployment
   , narrowing the gap with competitors
4. Seize high-growth segment opportunities
   such as FWA

From the perspective of the industry’s competitive landscape, the leading advantages of Jio and Airtel are still expanding, and the market pressure faced by Vodafone Idea cannot be fundamentally alleviated in the short term. Policy relief extends the existence of the market’s “four-operator” pattern, but in the medium to long term, the duopoly characteristics of the Indian telecom market will become more obvious.

---

[1] Morningstar - “Vodafone Idea Mulls Borrowing to Pay For Network Growth, Bloomberg Says, Citing Sources” (https://www.morningstar.com/news/dow-jones/202601092082/vodafone-idea-mulls-borrowing-to-pay-for-network-growth-bloomberg-says-citing-sources)

[2] The Economic Times - “Vodafone Idea is said to consider raising debt to boost growth” (https://m.economictimes.com/industry/telecom/telecom-news/vodafone-idea-is-said-to-consider-raising-debt-to-boost-growth/articleshow/126431580.cms)

[3] Livemint - “DoT freezes Vodafone Idea’s AGR dues; telco to pay ₹124 crore…” (https://www.livemint.com/companies/news/vodafone-idea-dot-agr-freeze-telecom-spectrum-11767930459159.html)

[4] The Economic Times - “Vodafone Idea confirms AGR relief, says Rs 124 crore to be paid annually over next 6 years” (https://m.economictimes.com/industry/telecom/telecom-news/vodafone-idea-confirms-agr-relief-says-rs-124-crore-to-be-paid-annually-over-next-6-years/articleshow/126426184.cms)

[5] Outlook Business - “How Vodafone Idea Will Service Its ₹2 tn AGR and Spectrum Dues After Govt’s Relief Explained” (https://www.outlookbusiness.com/corporate/how-vodafone-idea-will-service-its-2-tn-agr-and-spectrum-dues-after-govts-relief-explained)

[6] Emkay Global Research Note - “Vodafone Idea Analysis” (January 1, 2026)

[7] Light Reading - “How India’s telecom market quietly became a duopoly in 2025” (https://www.lightreading.com/wireless/how-india-s-telecom-market-quietly-became-a-duopoly-in-2025)

[8] The Economic Times - “Vi set to lose 3.5M users in Q3, snapping 9-mth trend” (https://m.economictimes.com/industry/telecom/telecom-news/vi-set-to-lose-3-5m-users-in-q3-snapping-9-mth-trend/articleshow/126380183.cms)

[9] IBEF - “Telecom Industry in India: Market Size, Growth & Future” (https://www.ibef.org/industry/telecommunications)