Analysis of Valuation Concerns and Investment Implications for AST SpaceMobile (ASTS)

Based on the information I have collected, I provide you with a detailed analysis report on Scotiabank’s downgrade of AST SpaceMobile’s stock rating.

---

Scotiabank (Bank of Nova Scotia) downgraded AST SpaceMobile’s stock rating from

on , maintaining a target price of approximately , which implies a [1][2].

This is another major rating downgrade following Barclays’ action on October 17, 2025, when it lowered ASTS from “Overweight” to “Underweight” [3].

---

According to the latest data, AST SpaceMobile’s P/B ratio ranges from

, while the average for its peer companies is only , and the average for the entire U.S. telecommunications industry is as low as [4][5]. This huge valuation gap indicates that the market is paying an extremely high premium for the company.

Valuation Metric	AST SpaceMobile	Peer Average	Industry Average
P/B Ratio	20.38x	7.1x	1.3x
P/S Ratio	8,721x	1.7x	N/A
EV/EBITDA	-93.71	N/A	N/A

AST SpaceMobile’s P/S ratio ranges from

, while the peer average is only [5][6]. This metric indicates that investors are paying an astronomical valuation for the company’s minimal current revenue.

Although the company achieved

in 2025 (Q3 revenue reached $14.74 million), it is still in a state of severe loss [6][7]:

• Annual Net Loss
  : Approximately $371 million
• EPS (TTM)
  : $-1.14
• Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Ratio
  : Negative (-66.85 to -85.52)

The current share price ($97.49) is close to the

, representing a from the all-time low ($17.50) [0]. The full-year 2025 gain ranges from , a surge that far exceeds the reasonable expectations of the company’s actual commercialization progress [5][8].

---

Institution	Rating	Target Price	Core View
Scotiabank	Sector Underperform	$42.9-$45.4	Significant valuation concerns
Barclays	Underweight	$60	Valuation has become “excessive” [3]
UBS	Neutral	$43	Downgraded from Buy
B. Riley Securities	Buy	$95	Bullish on long-term prospects
Cantor Fitzgerald	Buy	$30	Conservative target price

The average target price is

, implying a downside of approximately [1][2].

---

Scotiabank’s rating downgrade sends an important signal to the market:

. Investors need to re-examine the valuation framework for this sector:

• Growth expectations are fully priced in
  : The current share price implies extremely optimistic growth assumptions
• Technology execution risks
  : There are significant uncertainties regarding the deployment progress of the BlueBird satellite constellation, satellite hardware costs (projected at $2-2.2 billion), and subsequent Block 2 construction [8]
• Insufficient commercialization validation
  : Although the company has signed revenue commitments of over
  $1 billion
  , recurring service revenue has not been fully validated

For investors considering investing in the satellite communication sector, it is recommended to focus on the following key points:

Evaluation Dimension	Key Metrics	Risk Warning
Valuation Rationality	P/B, P/S, EV/Revenue	Avoid chasing targets with excessively high valuations
Commercialization Progress	User growth, ARPU, contract conversion rate	Focus on actual revenue conversion
Execution Capability	Satellite launch success rate, cost control	Assess technical risks
Liquidity	Cash reserves, financing capability	The company’s $3.2 billion in liquidity is a positive factor [6]
Competitive Landscape	Starlink, other satellite operators	Monitor changes in market share

There is significant valuation differentiation within the satellite communication sector:

• High-growth, high-valuation companies
  (such as ASTS): Face greater correction risks
• Mature and stable companies
  : May offer a more favorable risk-reward ratio

From a technical analysis perspective, ASTS exhibits the following characteristics [0]:

• Uptrend
  : In a state of pending breakout confirmation
• Overbought risk
  : RSI indicator shows overbought risk
• High beta
  : Beta of 2.69, meaning market volatility will be amplified
• Key resistance level
  : $97.94 (near current price)
• Key support level
  : $81.28

---

Scotiabank’s downgrade of AST SpaceMobile reflects concerns about a valuation bubble in the satellite communication sector. The core issue is:

.

For investors, this event reminds us to:

1. Maintain valuation discipline
   : Avoid being swayed by technological innovation and grand narratives
2. Focus on fundamentals
   : Actual revenue, user growth, and profitability are more important than vision
3. Diversify risks
   : Make differentiated allocations within the satellite communication sector
4. Wait for better entry points
   : Such as when valuations return to a reasonable range or the company achieves major commercial breakthroughs

Satellite communication technology does have revolutionary potential, but investors should distinguish between “disruptive technology” and “investable targets” to avoid paying excessive premiums for unfulfilled promises.

---

[1] Benzinga - AST SpaceMobile Analyst Ratings and Price Targets (https://www.benzinga.com/quote/ASTS/analyst-ratings)

[2] Tiblio - AST SpaceMobile Stock Overview (https://tiblio.com/research/tickers/ASTS)

[3] Yahoo Finance - Deere upgraded, AST SpaceMobile downgraded (https://finance.yahoo.com/news/deere-upgraded-ast-spacemobile-downgraded-133644470.html)

[4] Simply Wall St - Assessing AST SpaceMobile Valuation (https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/telecom/nasdaq-asts/ast-spacemobile/news/assessing-ast-spacemobile-asts-valuation-after-bluebird-6-la)

[5] Ainvest - Is AST SpaceMobile Still a Buy After Its 254% 2025 Surge (https://www.ainvest.com/news/ast-spacemobile-asts-buy-254-2025-surge-2601)

[6] GuruFocus - ASTS PB Ratio (https://www.gurufocus.com/term/pb-ratio/ASTS)

[7] Yahoo Finance - AST SpaceMobile Reassessing Valuation (https://finance.yahoo.com/news/ast-spacemobile-asts-reassessing-valuation-091540122.html)

[8] Seeking Alpha - AST SpaceMobile: Strong Progress, But Valuation Still Outruns Fundamentals (https://seekingalpha.com/article/4851547-ast-spacemobile-stock-strong-progress-but-valuation-still-outruns-fundamentals)

[0] Jinling AI - Market Data and Technical Analysis