Investment Impact Analysis of Insider Stock Sale Plans at Willis Lease Finance Corp (WLFC)

Based on web search data, WLFC’s core management conducted systematic stock reductions between 2024 and 2025, as detailed below [1][2]:

Insider	Position	Number of Transactions	Shares Sold	Valuation Amount
Charles F IV Willis	Executive Chairman	49 sales	90,700	~$14.55 million
Brian Richard Hole	President	4 sales	24,312	~$4.52 million
Scott B. Flaherty	CFO	4 sales	20,000	~$3.59 million
Austin Chandler Willis	CEO	11 sales	6,900	~$1.35 million

• Intensive selling occurred between August and December 2025 [1]
• August 12-14: Charles Willis sold 30,000 shares and 29,850 shares on consecutive days
• August: Brian Hole sold multiple times, totaling ~12,500 shares
• September-December: Austin Willis sold ~6,100 shares monthly on a regular basis [3]

Form 144 is a form required by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) for insiders to submit when planning to sell a large number of company stocks. Its core purposes include [4]:

• Transparency Requirements
  : Notify the SEC and the public of insiders’ plans to sell restricted or control securities
• Prevent Manipulation
  : Disclose large sales that may affect stock prices in advance
• Compliance Mechanism
  : Ensure adherence to Rule 144 under the 1933 Securities Act

These insider sales are likely based on Rule 10b5-1 pre-set trading plans [5], which have the following characteristics:

• Pre-designed Plan
  : Insiders set it up when not in possession of Material Non-Public Information (MNPI)
• Regular Execution
  : Automatically execute according to a pre-determined schedule to avoid suspicion of insider trading
• Legal Compliance
  : A standard practice for executives to diversify their investment portfolios

Indicator	Value	Year-over-Year Change
Annual Revenue	$569.2M	Record-breaking
Pretax Income	$152.6M	+127.4%
EPS (TTM)	$16.66	-
Net Profit Margin	17.87%	Excellent level
ROE	19.55%	Excellent
P/E Ratio	8.19x	Significantly undervalued

• Current Ratio: 1.81 (Good liquidity)
• Quick Ratio:1.44 (Strong short-term solvency)
• Financial Attitude Classification: Conservative type (Accounting prudence) [0]
• Liability Risk: Medium risk [0]

• Current Price (January 2025): $134.21
• 52-week Range: $114.01 - $229.67
• 1-year Return: -36.98%
• 3-year Return: +125.64%
• 5-year Return: +340.18%

• From August 2024 to January 2025, the stock price surged from $88 to $217.50 (+147%) [6]
• After intensive insider selling (August-December 2025), the stock price fell from the high of $229.67 to the current $134.21
• Technical analysis shows it is currently in a sideways consolidation phase, with a trading range reference of [$208.46, $223.29] [6]

Compared with peers, WLFC’s valuation is highly attractive:

Company	Market Cap (Billion USD)	P/E	P/S	Total Return Rate
WLFC	0.9	7.7	1.4	13.9%
Air Lease	7.2	7.0	2.5	15.6%
TransDigm	76.6	36.9	8.7	15.3%
Heico	45.7	66.2	10.2	1.6%

• Charles Willis, as founder and executive chairman, holds an extremely high proportion of shares
• Systematic reduction is a standard wealth management strategy
• Consistent with the characteristics of Rule 10b5-1 pre-set trading plans [5]

• The stock price rose 340% in 5 years; it is reasonable for insiders to cash in part of their gains
• The stock price reached an all-time high of $229.67 in August 2024, followed by intensive selling

• February 2025: The company acquired 30 LEAP engines to expand aviation support services [2]
• Successfully deployed nearly $1 billion in capital investment in 2024 [1]
• The joint venture engine leasing business with Mitsui continues to operate [2]

• CEO, CFO, President, and Chairman all reduced their holdings during the same period
• May signal management’s caution about the short-term outlook of the stock price

• Charles Willis sold up to 30,000 shares in a single transaction (valued at $4.5 million)
• The total reduction amount exceeded $24 million; although the proportion of the company’s market cap is small, the absolute value is considerable

• Selling occurred after the strong release of the 2024 financial report, which may reflect concerns about the sustainability of future growth

To determine whether insider selling is a cause for concern, consider the following:

• ✓
  Planned Sale
  : Within Rule 10b5-1 plan (Neutral to positive)
• ✓
  Excessive Proportion
  : Need to further verify the remaining shareholding ratio of insiders
• ✓
  Abnormal Timing
  : Sold after the company’s record performance (Neutral)
• ✓
  Historical Comparison
  : Need to compare with historical selling patterns
• Before Negative News
  : No such situation

Based on WLFC’s specific situation, the following assessment is given:

Evaluation Dimension	Score (1-10)	Explanation
Fundamental Quality	9/10	Strong financial performance, excellent ROE and profit margin
Valuation Attractiveness	9/10	P/E ratio of 8.19x is significantly lower than peers and historical levels
Insider Sale Signal	6/10	Some negative impact, but understandable as diversification
Industry Outlook	7/10	Aviation industry recovery, steady demand for engine leasing
Technical Aspect	5/10	Short-term sideways, unclear direction

1. Short-term Stock Price Pressure
   : Insider selling may psychologically suppress the stock price
2. Industry Cyclical Risk
   : The aviation industry is greatly affected by the macroeconomy
3. Liquidity Risk
   : The average daily trading volume is only 50,000 shares; institutional inflows and outflows may cause volatility
4. Liability Risk
   : Financial analysis shows a medium level of liability risk [0]

• ✅ Value Investors: Low valuation, high ROE, strong cash flow
• ✅ Long-term Investors: 340% 5-year return, obvious compound effect
• ⚠️ Short-term Traders: Insufficient liquidity, high volatility

1. Existing Holdings
   : Continue to hold, focus on Q1 2025 financial report and capital allocation strategy
2. New Investors
   : Build positions in batches, buy gradually near the technical support level of $208.46 [6]
3. Stop-loss Setting
   : It is recommended to set a stop-loss below $114 (52-week low)

Investors should focus on:

• ✓ Sustained profitability of quarterly financial reports
• ✓ Whether insiders continue to reduce or switch to increasing holdings
• ✓ Recovery of aviation industry demand
• ✓ Company’s capital allocation efficiency (balance of dividends/repurchase/reinvestment)

Against the background of the company’s record-breaking performance in 2024, the current P/E ratio of only 8.19x provides an extremely attractive safety margin [0][1].

Although there may be short-term technical adjustment pressure, in the long run, WLFC is still worthy of focus by value investors due to its strong profitability, conservative financial policies, and industry-leading position. It is recommended that investors pay attention to whether insiders complete their planned reduction and whether the company uses stock repurchases to hedge the market impact caused by the reduction.

---

[0] Jinling API Data - WLFC Company Overview, Financial Analysis, Real-time Quotes, Technical Analysis (Company Financial Data, Stock Price Performance, Technical Indicators)

[1] Nasdaq - “Willis Lease Finance Corporation Reports Record Annual Revenues of $569.2 Million and Pre-Tax Income of $152.6 Million for 2024” (March 10, 2025)
https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/willis-lease-finance-corporation-reports-record-annual-revenues-5692-million-and-pre-tax

[2] Nasdaq - “Willis Lease Finance Corporation Acquires 30 LEAP Engines from CFM International to Expand Aviation Support Services” (February 20, 2025)
https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/willis-lease-finance-corporation-acquires-30-leap-engines-cfm-international-expand

[3] Seeking Alpha - “WLFC Willis Lease Finance Corporation Stock Price & Overview” (Insider Transaction Data)
https://seekingalpha.com/symbol/WLFC

[4] SmartAsset - “Form 144: What Is It, Who Files It and Who Gets It?”
https://smartasset.com/financial-advisor/form-144

[5] Mayer Brown - “WHAT’S THE DEAL? Rule 10b5-1 Plans” (January 2025)
https://www.mayerbrown.com/-/media/files/perspectives-events/publications/2025/01/whats-the-deal--10b51-plans-january-2025.pdf

[6] Jinling API Data - WLFC Stock Daily Price Data (Price Trend from August 2024 to January 2025)